The Debate with the Vulgar-Atheist Radical on the Secularity of the State (Answer to the Article O. In. Martyshyna): Concept and ontology of secularity by I. In. Ponkina is an in-depth and multi-layered study that addresses critical issues concerning the secularity of the state and its relationship with religion. This work not only responds to the criticism expressed by O. In. Martyshin, but also opens new horizons for reflection on how secularism can be understood and interpreted in modern society. The book will be of interest to a wide range of readers, including students and teachers of humanities, philosophers, sociologists, as well as anyone interested in religion, politics and their interaction. If you are looking for a deep analysis of secularism and its place in the modern world, then this work will be a real find for you. Ponkin addresses readers who seek to understand how religious and secular values can coexist, as well as those who want to understand the complex issues surrounding atheism and its impact on society. In his book, the author raises a number of topical topics, such as the nature of secularism, its philosophical foundations and social consequences. Ponkin not only criticizes radical atheistic views, but also offers alternative approaches to understanding secularism, which can be useful for the formation of a more harmonious society. His arguments are based on a thorough analysis of historical and contemporary examples, which makes the text not only theoretically sound, but also practical. Style and . In. Ponkina is clear and logical, which allows the reader to easily follow his thought. He skillfully combines academic rigor with the accessibility of presentation, which makes his work attractive to a wide audience. In his previous works, the author also explored topics related to philosophy, sociology and culture, which confirms his status as an expert in this field. The book Controversy with the Vulgar-Atheist Radical not only responds to the challenges posed by radical ideas, but also offers a constructive dialogue between different views on secularism. Ponkin emphasizes the importance of respect for different worldviews and the need to find compromises in a society where religious and secular values can coexist. This work will be an important contribution to the discussion about the future of the secular state and its role in the lives of citizens. If you are looking for books that raise issues of secularism, religion, and atheism, then you may be interested in works such as The Secular State and Its Enemies. C. Dugin or "Religion and Secularism: Dialogue of Cultures" H. N. Nosova . These books also offer different perspectives on the interaction of religion and the state, which can complement your understanding of the topic. In conclusion, the “Dispute with the vulgar-atheistic radical about the secularity of the state” is not just a response to criticism, but a whole world of ideas that invites the reader to reflection and discussion. This work will be a valuable resource for all those interested in philosophy, sociology and culture, as well as those who seek to understand the complex relationship between religion and the state in the modern world.